Discover the key differences between tritoon and pontoon boats, including stability, speed, capacity, and cost, to choose the best boat for your needs.
When deciding between a tritoon and a pontoon boat, understanding their differences is crucial to selecting the vessel that aligns with your boating lifestyle. Both types of boats offer unique advantages, catering to different preferences, budgets, and water activities. This article dives deep into the distinctions between tritoon and pontoon boats, exploring their design, performance, capacity, cost, and ideal use cases. Whether you’re a casual cruiser, an avid angler, or a watersports enthusiast, this guide will help you make an informed decision.
What is a Pontoon Boat?
A pontoon boat is a flat-decked vessel supported by two cylindrical tubes, or pontoons, typically made of aluminum. These tubes provide buoyancy, allowing the boat to float on water while offering a stable platform for various activities. Pontoon boats gained popularity in the 1960s for their simplicity and versatility, designed primarily for low-speed cruising on calm, sheltered waters like lakes and rivers. They are ideal for leisurely outings, fishing, or relaxing with family and friends.
Key Features of Pontoon Boats
- Design: Two pontoon tubes beneath a flat deck.
- Typical Size: Ranges from 14 to 28 feet.
- Capacity: Can carry 8–15 passengers, depending on size.
- Horsepower: Typically equipped with engines ranging from 25 to 150 horsepower.
- Use Cases: Best for calm waters, fishing, cruising, and swimming.
- Advantages: Affordable, lightweight, easier to tow, and suitable for shallow waters.
What is a Tritoon Boat?
A tritoon boat is essentially a pontoon boat with an additional third tube, often placed in the center and slightly lower or larger in diameter than the outer tubes. This design enhances stability, weight distribution, and performance. Introduced as an evolution of the twin-tube pontoon, tritoons gained traction in the 1980s, with manufacturers like Manitou trademarking terms like “TriToon” to highlight their improved handling and speed.
Key Features of Tritoon Boats
- Design: Three pontoon tubes for enhanced buoyancy and stability.
- Typical Size: Ranges from 22 to 30 feet.
- Capacity: Can accommodate 10–21 passengers, depending on size.
- Horsepower: Supports engines from 90 to 900 horsepower, including dual-engine setups.
- Use Cases: Ideal for watersports, rough waters, and larger groups.
- Advantages: Superior stability, higher speeds, and better handling in choppy conditions.
Key Differences Between Tritoon and Pontoon Boats
The primary distinction between a tritoon and a pontoon boat lies in the number of tubes, but this difference leads to several other variations in performance, capacity, and cost. Below, we explore these differences in detail.
1. Number of Tubes
- Pontoon: Two tubes provide sufficient buoyancy for calm waters but may struggle in rough conditions.
- Tritoon: Three tubes distribute weight more evenly, improving stability and handling.
2. Stability and Handling
Pontoon boats are stable for casual cruising but can lean outward during turns, especially at higher speeds, which may cause discomfort or sliding. Their design limits performance in choppy waters, where waves over two feet can pose challenges. Tritoons, with their third tube, offer superior stability, maintaining a flatter profile during turns and handling rough waters more effectively. The center tube reduces drag and allows the boat to glide smoothly, making tritoons more seaworthy.
3. Horsepower and Speed
Tritoons can accommodate more powerful engines due to their enhanced structural integrity. For example, Bennington’s pontoon boats typically range from 25 to 150 horsepower, while their tritoon models, like those in the Q Series, can support up to 900 horsepower with twin engines. This allows tritoons to reach speeds of up to 50 mph, compared to pontoons, which typically max out at 40 mph. The increased horsepower makes tritoons ideal for watersports like tubing, wakeboarding, or waterskiing.
4. Weight and Capacity
The additional tube in a tritoon increases its weight but also boosts its capacity. A 24-foot pontoon with two 25-inch tubes might carry 13 passengers and 2,315 pounds, while a tritoon of the same length with three 25-inch tubes can handle 15 passengers and 2,697 pounds. Larger tritoons, like Bennington’s 30-foot models, can accommodate up to 21 people. This makes tritoons suitable for larger groups or heavier loads, though their added weight requires a more robust towing vehicle.
5. Cost
Pontoon boats are generally more affordable than tritoons due to their simpler design and lower horsepower requirements. For instance, a 22-foot Sun Tracker pontoon with a 115-horsepower engine might cost around $36,000, while a comparable tritoon with a 150-horsepower engine could be priced at $44,000. Bennington’s pontoon boats start at approximately $17,000 for the SV Line, while their luxury tritoon models in the Q Series can exceed $200,000. The higher cost of tritoons reflects their enhanced performance and features.
6. Fuel Efficiency
Pontoon boats are typically more fuel-efficient due to their lighter weight and lower horsepower engines. Tritoons, with their additional tube and larger engines, consume more fuel, especially at higher speeds. However, tritoons often have larger fuel tanks (e.g., 63 gallons vs. 28 gallons for a comparable pontoon), allowing for longer trips without refueling.
7. Trailering and Storage
Pontoon boats are lighter and easier to tow, making them ideal for those who frequently transport their boat. Tritoons, being heavier, require a larger trailer and a vehicle with sufficient towing capacity. Additionally, tritoons’ larger size demands more storage space, which is a consideration for seasonal boaters.
Performance Comparison
To illustrate the performance differences, consider the following table comparing a 24-foot pontoon and tritoon model:
| Feature | Pontoon (2×25-inch tubes) | Tritoon (3×25-inch tubes) |
|---|---|---|
| Passenger Capacity | 13 (2,315 lbs) | 15 (2,697 lbs) |
| Max Horsepower | 150 HP | 225 HP |
| Top Speed | ~40 mph | ~50 mph |
| Fuel Capacity | 28 gal | 63 gal |
| Dry Weight | ~2,379 lbs | ~3,250 lbs |
This table highlights the tritoon’s ability to handle more passengers, higher horsepower, and greater fuel capacity, though it comes with increased weight.
Chart: Performance Comparison
Below is a chart visualizing the performance differences between pontoon and tritoon boats.
Use Cases: Which Boat Suits Your Lifestyle?
Choosing between a pontoon and a tritoon depends on how you plan to use the boat. Below, we explore common applications and which boat type is best suited for each.
1. Leisurely Cruising
Pontoon boats excel in calm, sheltered waters like small lakes or rivers. Their lightweight design and affordability make them perfect for relaxed outings, such as sunset cruises or picnics on the water. Tritoons, while capable of leisurely cruising, are overkill for this purpose unless you anticipate larger groups or rougher conditions.
2. Fishing
Pontoon boats are popular among anglers for their stability in calm waters and ample deck space for fishing gear. They are easier to maneuver in tight spaces, making them ideal for small lakes. Tritoons, however, are better for fishing in larger bodies of water, such as oceans or expansive lakes, where their stability in rough conditions and ability to support larger engines allow for quicker travel between fishing spots.
3. Watersports
Tritoons are the clear choice for watersports enthusiasts. Their ability to handle higher horsepower engines (70 HP or more) and maintain stability at speed makes them ideal for towing skiers, wakeboarders, or tubers. Pontoon boats can support watersports with sufficient horsepower, but they lack the tritoon’s handling and speed capabilities.
4. Rough Water Navigation
Tritoons outperform pontoons in choppy or open waters due to their third tube, which reduces drag and enhances stability. Pontoon boats are less suited for waves over two feet, as they may take on water or become unstable. If you boat on large lakes or coastal waters, a tritoon is the safer and more comfortable option.
5. Large Groups
For those hosting larger gatherings, tritoons offer greater capacity and deck space. A 28-foot tritoon can carry up to 15–21 passengers, compared to a pontoon’s typical limit of 8–15. This makes tritoons ideal for family reunions or group outings.
Cost and Specifications
The cost of pontoon and tritoon boats varies based on brand, size, engine, and features.
The following table summarizes the key differences between pontoon and tritoon boats for a 24-foot model:
| Feature | Pontoon (2×25-inch tubes) | Tritoon (3×25-inch tubes) |
|---|---|---|
| Number of Tubes | 2 | 3 |
| Passenger Capacity | 13 (2,315 lbs) | 15 (2,697 lbs) |
| Max Horsepower | 150 HP | 225 HP |
| Top Speed | ~40 mph | ~50 mph |
| Fuel Capacity | 28 gal | 63 gal |
| Dry Weight | ~2,379 lbs | ~3,250 lbs |
| Price Range | $15,000–$50,000 | $20,000–$200,000 |
| Best Use | Calm waters, cruising, fishing | Watersports, rough waters |
| Fuel Efficiency | Higher | Lower |
| Towing/Storage | Easier | Requires larger vehicle/space |
Cost Considerations
- Pontoons: More budget-friendly, with lower upfront costs and better fuel efficiency. Ideal for casual boaters or those with smaller towing vehicles.
- Tritoons: Higher initial cost but offer better resale value due to their popularity and versatility. The added expense is justified for those seeking performance and stability.
Pros and Cons of Pontoon and Tritoon Boats
Pontoon Boats
Pros:
- More affordable, with prices starting at $15,000.
- Lightweight and easier to tow.
- Ideal for shallow waters due to a shallower draft.
- Better fuel efficiency.
- Smaller turning radius for tight spaces.
Cons:
- Less stable in rough waters.
- Limited horsepower and speed (up to 40 mph).
- Lower passenger and weight capacity.
- May lean outward during turns, reducing comfort.
Tritoon Boats
Pros:
- Superior stability and handling, especially in choppy conditions.
- Higher horsepower and speed (up to 50 mph).
- Greater passenger and weight capacity.
- Better suited for watersports and large groups.
- Enhanced resale value.
Cons:
- Higher cost, starting at $20,000 and up to $200,000.
- Heavier, requiring a larger towing vehicle and storage space.
- Less fuel-efficient due to larger engines.
Choosing the Right Boat for You
When deciding between a pontoon and a tritoon, consider the following factors:
- Budget: If cost is a primary concern, a pontoon boat offers a more affordable entry point. However, tritoons provide better long-term value for those willing to invest in performance.
- Intended Use: For casual cruising, fishing, or swimming in calm waters, a pontoon is sufficient. For watersports, rough waters, or larger groups, a tritoon is the better choice.
- Boating Location: Small lakes and rivers favor pontoons, while larger lakes, coastal waters, or areas with choppy conditions call for a tritoon.
- Towing and Storage: Ensure your vehicle can tow a tritoon’s added weight and that you have adequate storage space.
- Test Drive: Always test drive both types to experience their handling and performance firsthand.
Real-World Example
Consider a boater choosing between a 20-foot Sylvan pontoon with a 115 HP engine ($36,000) and a 21-foot Princecraft tritoon with a 115 HP engine ($38,000). The pontoon offers a desirable seating layout and double bimini tops, ideal for shade-loving cruisers. However, the tritoon gets on plane faster, handles nose weight better, and is more stable for occasional tubing. For a couple who primarily cruises and swims on a lake but wants to handle occasional rough chop, the tritoon’s $2,000 premium may be worth the investment for its versatility and smoother ride.
User Insights from Boating Communities
Boating enthusiasts on platforms like forums and social media often share their experiences, providing valuable insights:
- Performance: Users like “captain28570” note that a tritoon with a 150 HP engine can reach 44–45 mph, significantly faster than a pontoon’s 28–32 mph with a 115 HP engine.
- Resale Value: Commenters like “lakelost” emphasize that tritoons have a larger target market and better resale value, making them a smarter long-term investment.
- Rough Water Handling: “Fishinado” highlights that tritoons keep the bow up in large waves, preventing the “nose-dive” common in pontoons.
- Brand Preferences: Boaters like “JoeJunior” prefer brands like Bennington, Manitou, or Ranger over Tracker due to build quality and fewer reported issues.
Conclusion
The choice between a pontoon and a tritoon boat boils down to your boating goals, budget, and the conditions you’ll encounter. Pontoon boats are affordable, lightweight, and perfect for leisurely cruises or fishing in calm waters. Tritoons, with their third tube, offer superior stability, speed, and capacity, making them ideal for watersports, rough waters, or larger groups. While tritoons come with a higher price tag, their performance and resale value often justify the cost for those seeking a versatile boating experience.
Before deciding, test drive both types and consider your towing capacity, storage options, and local water conditions. Whether you choose a pontoon for its simplicity or a tritoon for its power, both promise countless hours of enjoyment on the water.
Happy Boating!
Share Tritoon vs. Pontoon: What’s the Difference? with your friends and leave a comment below with your thoughts.
Read The Ultimate Guide to Anti Nausea Wristbands until we meet in the next article.