Garmin Echomap Vs GPSmap units: Which is better

Compare Garmin ECHOMAP vs GPSMAP chartplotters to find the best for your boating and fishing needs. Explore features, specs, and prices for informed decisions.

When navigating the open waters or targeting the perfect fishing spot, having the right marine electronics can make all the difference. Garmin, a leading name in marine navigation, offers two prominent chartplotter series: ECHOMAP and GPSMAP. Each caters to distinct user needs, from casual anglers to professional mariners. This in-depth comparison explores their features, specifications, performance, and pricing to help you choose the best unit for your boating and fishing adventures.

Understanding Garmin’s ECHOMAP and GPSMAP Series

Both the ECHOMAP and GPSMAP series are designed to provide reliable navigation and fishfinding capabilities, but they target different audiences. The ECHOMAP series is tailored for anglers and recreational boaters seeking affordable, user-friendly solutions with robust sonar and mapping features. The GPSMAP series, on the other hand, is built for professional boaters and serious anglers who require advanced networking, high-resolution displays, and compatibility with a wide range of marine accessories like radar and cameras.

Target Audience

• ECHOMAP: Ideal for recreational anglers and boaters fishing in inland lakes, rivers, or shallow coastal waters. It’s perfect for those who prioritize simplicity, affordability, and fishing-specific features.
• GPSMAP: Suited for professional anglers, charter boat operators, and mariners navigating offshore or in challenging conditions. It offers advanced functionality for complex marine environments.

Key Features Comparison

ECHOMAP Series: Affordable and Angler-Focused

The ECHOMAP series, including models like ECHOMAP Plus, UHD, UHD2, and Ultra, is designed to deliver high-quality sonar and mapping at a budget-friendly price. Here are its standout features:

• Sonar Capabilities: Equipped with CHIRP sonar, ClearVü (down-scanning), and SideVü (side-scanning) sonar, ECHOMAP units provide detailed underwater imaging, ideal for locating fish and underwater structures. Some models support Panoptix LiveScope for real-time sonar imaging.
• Preloaded Maps: Comes with LakeVü g3 or BlueChart g3 maps, covering over 17,000 lakes with 1-foot contours and coastal areas, respectively. Quickdraw Contours software allows users to create custom maps on the water.
• Display Options: Available in screen sizes from 4 to 12 inches, with sunlight-readable touchscreen displays for intuitive operation.
• Networking: Limited networking capabilities, primarily supporting connections with other ECHOMAP units via the Garmin Marine Network. Some models (e.g., Ultra) offer two Ethernet ports for enhanced connectivity.
• Transducer Power: Typically supports 500-600W transducers, sufficient for shallow to moderate depths (up to 350 feet).
• Additional Features: Wi-Fi and Bluetooth for syncing with Garmin’s ActiveCaptain app, dual SD card slots (Ultra models), and a 5-10 Hz GPS receiver for accurate positioning.

GPSMAP Series: Advanced and Versatile

The GPSMAP series, including models like the 8000 and 8400 series, is Garmin’s premium offering, designed for advanced navigation and integration. Key features include:

• Sonar Capabilities: Supports advanced sonar systems, including CHIRP, ClearVü, SideVü, and Panoptix LiveScope, with compatibility for up to 1kW transducers, ideal for deeper waters.
• Preloaded Maps: Features BlueChart g3 or LakeVü g3 maps with support for custom map downloads and Auto Guidance+ for advanced route planning.
• Display Options: Offers high-resolution touchscreen displays ranging from 7 to 24 inches, providing crisp visuals even in bright sunlight.
• Networking: Advanced BlueNet networking for faster data sharing with other GPSMAP units, radar, cameras, and marine electronics. Supports NMEA 2000 and NMEA 0183 for seamless integration.
• Additional Features: Radar compatibility, satellite weather support, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, and voice command functionality on select models. Some units allow sonar history scrolling and video recording via ActiveCaptain.
• Build Quality: Constructed with less plastic and higher durability, designed for rugged marine environments, including saltwater.

Detailed Feature Comparison

To provide a clearer picture, here’s a side-by-side comparison of key specifications:

Chart: Feature Comparison

Performance in Real-World Scenarios

ECHOMAP: Ideal for Inshore and Freshwater Fishing

For anglers like Mponte115, fishing in shallow waters (less than 40 feet) on a 20-foot Jones Brothers Cape Fisherman, the ECHOMAP series is a practical choice. Its 500–600W sonar is more than sufficient for shallow depths, providing clear images of fish and underwater structures. The GT54 or GT56 transducers, recommended by users like GregMachy, enhance sonar performance for inshore fishing in areas like Buzzards Bay, MA. The Quickdraw Contours feature allows anglers to map their favorite fishing spots, which is particularly useful for crappie or bass fishing in lakes and rivers.

The ECHOMAP Ultra models (10” and 12”) offer advantages over the UHD series, including:

• Two Ethernet ports for connecting multiple units or accessories like Panoptix without a network expander.
• Dual SD card slots for storing custom maps.
• 10 Hz GPS receiver for smoother tracking compared to the 5 Hz in UHD models.

User coiloil37’s experience with the ECHOMAP Ultra 105sv paired with a GT51 transducer demonstrates its effectiveness for trolling offshore, marking bait schools and billfish at speeds up to 20 knots, though side-scan performance diminishes at high speeds.

GPSMAP: Built for Offshore and Complex Navigation

The GPSMAP series excels in demanding environments, such as offshore fishing or navigating congested waterways. Its 1kW sonar capability supports deeper water fishing (up to 5,000 feet with the right transducer), making it ideal for users like FishInHatteras252, who fish in depths up to 350 feet for tuna, mahi, and bottom species. The ability to integrate radar and satellite weather enhances safety in low-visibility conditions, a feature absent in ECHOMAP units.

GPSMAP units also offer faster processors and higher-resolution displays, as noted by Astrochris, ensuring smooth operation and clear visuals. The ability to scroll back through sonar history, as mentioned by MichAngler, is a valuable feature for reviewing fish patterns. Additionally, the modular design allows users to choose mapping-only units for dedicated LiveScope setups, as highlighted by BobKlindworth, potentially reducing costs for specific needs.

Durability and Build Quality

Both series are built to withstand marine environments, but they differ slightly in construction:

• ECHOMAP: Lightweight and water-resistant, suitable for smaller boats and inshore use. While durable, it uses more plastic components, which may be less robust in extreme conditions.
• GPSMAP: Features a rugged, military-grade build with less plastic, making it better suited for saltwater and harsh weather. Users like Astrochris note that GPSMAP units receive software updates for longer periods, enhancing longevity.

For saltwater environments, both series are viable, but GPSMAP’s superior build quality and higher weatherproof ratings make it the preferred choice for extended offshore use.

Pricing and Value

ECHOMAP Pricing

• ECHOMAP Plus (4”–9”): $200–$600 (e.g., ECHOMAP Plus 73cv: ~$349.99 with transducer).
• ECHOMAP UHD/UHD2 (6”–9”): $400–$900 (e.g., ECHOMAP UHD 94sv: ~$649.99 with GT54 transducer, as noted by Fly Rod NYC).
• ECHOMAP Ultra (10”–12”): $1,000–$1,500 (e.g., ECHOMAP Ultra 102sv: ~$1,199.99).

GPSMAP Pricing

• GPSMAP 7”–9” Models: $800–$1,500 (e.g., GPSMAP 943xsv: ~$1,399.99).
• GPSMAP 10”–12” Models: $1,800–$3,000 (e.g., GPSMAP 1242xsv: ~$2,199.99).
• GPSMAP 16”–24” Models: $3,500–$5,000+ (e.g., GPSMAP 8416xsv: ~$5,099.99).

Value for Money

• ECHOMAP: Offers excellent value for anglers who don’t need radar or advanced networking. Its lower price point and fishing-focused features make it a cost-effective choice for inshore and freshwater use.
• GPSMAP: Justifies its higher cost with advanced features, durability, and versatility. It’s a worthwhile investment for professional mariners or those requiring radar and deep-water sonar.

Choosing Between Two 9” Units vs. One 12” Unit

For users like Mponte115, deciding between two 9” units or one 12” unit depends on boat size, budget, and functionality:

• Two 9” ECHOMAP UHD Units: Provides dual-screen flexibility for viewing sonar and maps simultaneously. However, networking multiple units with Panoptix may require a network expander, increasing costs (~$1,300–$1,800 for two units with transducers).
• One 12” ECHOMAP Ultra or GPSMAP Unit: Offers a larger, single-screen experience with better performance (e.g., faster swiping/panning, as noted by Buriedpast). The Ultra’s dual Ethernet ports simplify networking, and a 12” GPSMAP provides radar support if needed (~$1,200–$2,200).

For a 20-foot boat fishing in shallow waters, a single 12” ECHOMAP Ultra with a GT54 or GT56 transducer is recommended for its larger display and networking simplicity, assuming budget allows.

User Testimonials and Community Insights

Online forums like The Hull Truth provide valuable user feedback:

• GregMachy (Lake Shore, MD): Recommends ECHOMAP for shallow-water fishing on smaller boats, emphasizing the adequacy of 500–600W sonar for depths under 40 feet.
• coiloil37 (Queensland): Praises the ECHOMAP Ultra 105sv for offshore trolling, noting its ability to mark bait and fish effectively.
• Astrochris (Canada): Highlights GPSMAP’s superior build quality and longer software support, ideal for saltwater durability.
• FishInHatteras252: Seeks advice for a 26’ C-Hawk, confirming ECHOMAP’s suitability for inshore fishing and GPSMAP’s advantages for occasional offshore trips.

Recommendations for Specific Use Cases

For Recreational Anglers (Inshore/Lakes)

• Best Choice: ECHOMAP UHD or Ultra (9”–12”)
• Why: Affordable, with advanced sonar (CHIRP, ClearVü, SideVü) and Quickdraw Contours for custom mapping. Ideal for depths under 350 feet.
• Recommended Model: ECHOMAP Ultra 102sv with GT56 transducer (~$1,199.99).

For Professional Boaters/Offshore Anglers

• Best Choice: GPSMAP 943xsv or 1242xsv
• Why: Supports radar, 1kW sonar, and advanced networking for deep-water fishing and complex navigation.
• Recommended Model: GPSMAP 1242xsv with GT54 transducer (~$2,199.99).

For Mixed Inshore/Offshore Use

• Best Choice: GPSMAP 943xsv
• Why: Balances cost and advanced features, with radar compatibility for occasional offshore trips and robust sonar for inshore fishing.
• Recommended Model: GPSMAP 943xsv (~$1,399.99).

Conclusion

Choosing between Garmin’s ECHOMAP and GPSMAP series depends on your boating and fishing needs. The ECHOMAP series is the go-to for recreational anglers and small boat owners, offering affordable, fishing-focused features like advanced sonar and custom mapping. The GPSMAP series is ideal for professional mariners and serious anglers needing radar, deep-water sonar, and extensive networking capabilities. For shallow-water fishing on smaller boats, an ECHOMAP Ultra 10” or 12” unit provides excellent value, while GPSMAP units like the 943xsv or 1242xsv are better for offshore adventures or complex setups. Evaluate your budget, boat size, and desired features to make the best choice for your next adventure on the water.

Happy Boating!

Share Garmin Echomap Vs GPSmap units: Which is better with your friends and leave a comment below with your thoughts.

Read How Does A Fluke-Style Anchor Hold A Recreational Boat? until we meet in the next article.